It's official, men and women ARE from the same planet
Not so different: The difference between men and women is down to the way they were brought up, scientists claim
It's official, men and women ARE from the same planet
16th August 2010
Scientists would have us believe that men and women are so different they could hail from different planets.
But a new book claims the difference between the genders is down to the way we are brought up.
It says the idea we are hard-wired at birth, as promoted by 1992 bestseller Men are from Mars, Women are from Venus, is outdated.
In fact it is nurture, rather than nature, that has the largest effect on skills, attributes and personalities. So boys aren’t born with better map-reading and parking skills.
And girls don’t come into the world able to multi-task and communicate better.
Instead, we are steered
towards gender-defined skills by
parents and teachers.
According to the book, Delusions of
Gender, by Cordelia Fine, a
Melbourne University psychologist, there
are no major neurological differences.
There may be slight variations in the
brains of women and men but the
wiring is soft, not hard.
Dr Lise Eliot, of Chicago Medical
School, agrees.
She said: ‘Children don’t inherit
intellectual differences.
They learn
them. They are a result of what we
expect a boy or a girl to be.’
‘Yes, boys and girls, men and
women, are different,’ Dr Eliot told
the New Scientist. ‘But most of those
differences are far smaller than the
Men are from Mars, Women are from
Venus stereotypes suggest.’
‘Every skill, attribute and personality trait is moulded by experience.’ Professor Robert Plomin, of the Institute of Psychiatry, in London, said: ‘People ignore huge similarity between boys and girls and instead exaggerate wildly the tiny difference between them. It drives me wild.’
Article: HERE



I am surprised these results came from a psychologist. Usually it is us, sociologist who step up to make this claim. I wish I could buy into it as a neat package, but there are still too many medical studies concerning the brain, endocrine and related areas that do not come to her conclusion. Nature v Nuture has been heatedly debated for many years. I will wait for another few more studies before I change my hypothesis.
Reply to this